Every year since 1936, Princeton University had awarded the William Winston Roper Trophy to the standout athlete of the school’s senior class. In 1973, the honor went to Carl Barisich, a defensive tackle drafted by the NFL’s Cleveland Browns.
Barisich’s award was a little different than the forty that had come before it. 1973 was the first year that Princeton’s graduating class comprised both men and women–including, of course, female athletes. Rather than pit the genders against each other, Princeton reserved the Roper Trophy for the best male athlete. A second distinction, the Senior Sportswoman Award, would be given to the outstanding female.
The women of Princeton’s first coed class had fully integrated themselves into the school’s athletic life, excelling in squash, swimming, and crew. But there was really no competition for the first Senior Sportswoman, named by the university on June 11th. Without question, the honor belonged to tennis captain Marjory Gengler.
Gengler won every set she played as an undergraduate, and the team as a whole was nearly as successful. In May 1973, Princeton Alumni Weekly put her on the cover, with the headline, “Princeton’s Best Athlete.” No more qualifiers were needed. The Eastern intercollegiate circuit wasn’t exactly the pinnacle of competitive tennis, but Gengler’s exploits extended further. The USLTA rated her the top singles and doubles player in the region, and she won a mixed doubles match at Wimbledon in 1972.
Some women in Princeton’s first coed class felt constant pressure to act as a representative for their gender. Gengler didn’t want that, and she almost said no to Princeton for that very reason. Tennis made it easier. “The men’s team welcomed us, didn’t make us feel like women’s libbers,” she said. “Now we have forty women in what used to be a traditional men’s club and the men are afraid we’re going to turn it into a sorority.”
After graduation, Gengler could have opted to join the women’s tour. She played a handful of tournaments in the summer of 1973, coming within one victory of qualifying for Wimbledon. Ultimately, she became an honorary member of the men’s tour instead. She married Stan Smith in 1974 and traveled the circuit with her new husband.
Back at Princeton, Gengler’s positive experience proved to be representative after all. At graduation, the salutatorian declaimed–in Latin, as was the tradition–“Ut tempora mutantur … vobis tamen persuadetis ut radix malorum non sit co-educatio.” Translated to the common tongue: As times change, you become convinced that co-education is not the root of evil.
* * *
This post is part of my series about the 1973 season, Battles, Boycotts, and Breakouts. Keep up with the project by checking the TennisAbstract.com front page, which shows an up-to-date Table of Contents after I post each installment.
You can also subscribe to the blog to receive each new post by email: